Every NFL Team’s Best Player (GOAT)

[CatManTrue]

Here’s an interesting list of each NFL franchise’s GOAT player.

Sadly, none are NU alumni, although we at least played a few of them:

 

[SmellyCat]

Hey...one is the brother of an NU player. And I saw him at the 'Plex once.

 

[NURoseBowl]

Your list here is pretty solid. Might proffer Curtis Martin for Darrell Revis, maybe?

 

[lou v]

Here’s an interesting list of each NFL franchise’s GOAT player.

Sadly, none are NU alumni, although we at least played a few of them:

View embedded media

I'd put Fran Tarkenton ahead of Randy Moss for the Vikings.

I also think Sammy Baugh was probably a greater "Commander" than Darrell Green, but very few people who saw him play are still alive so I get it.

 

[its_the_sauce]

Manning over Unitas????

 

[timbfischer]

Very light on OL. Munoz the only one I see. A case could definitely be made for Walter Jones over Russell Wilson in Seattle, or Orlando Pace over Donald for the Rams.

 

[FeralFelidae]

I think it's funny that Warren Moon never wore a Titans uniform, nor did he participate in the franchise's lone Super Bowl, yet he is considered the best Titan of all time.

(He was pretty darn good, though.)

 

[CatManTrue]

I think it's funny that Warren Moon never wore a Titans uniform, nor did he participate in the franchise's lone Super Bowl, yet he is considered the best Titan of all time.

(He was pretty darn good, though.)

Give Skoronski a few years and he’ll fix that.

 

[TheC]

When your franchise's best player ever is Matt Ryan, you are not a franchise that has seen a lot of success. Didn't Deion start his career in Atlanta?

 

[FeralFelidae]

Didn't Deion start his career in Atlanta?

So did Brett Favre.

 

[Katatonic]

If it weren't for JB, the great Otto would be on the list.

For such an underperforming franchise, the Bears could have another RB, Sayers, on the list and a good # of defensive players.

 

[FeralFelidae]

Also, I have to wonder if O. J. Simpson would have been the pick for the Bills except for reasons.

 

[NURoseBowl]

If it weren't for JB, the great Otto would be on the list.

For such an underperforming franchise, the Bears could have another RB, Sayers, on the list and a good # of defensive players.

Can never argue against Payton, but what you say here is true as well.

 

[NURoseBowl]

I'd put Fran Tarkenton ahead of Randy Moss for the Vikings.

I also think Sammy Baugh was probably a greater "Commander" than Darrell Green, but very few people who saw him play are still alive so I get it.

Hard to call Moss a poor choice, but Tarkenton crossed my mind as well. Grew up watching him dissecting the Bears in the early '70's.