ADVERTISEMENT

Historic Hypothetical...

ChappyCat

Well-Known Member
Gold Member
Sep 19, 2015
580
471
63
43
Michigan
Historic Hypothetical:
If Darnell Autry got injured during the 1995 season



We all loved the 1995 season. It was clearly the turning point of Northwestern football. Imagine this scenario, though. During the 4th game of the season against Indiana, the Heisman finalist injures his leg and is done for the season. Northwestern is forced to turn to sophomores Adrian Autry (no relation) and Faraji Leary. Adrian Autry averaged 3.7 yards per carry and Leary 3.3 but mostly in mop up time. There wasn’t a lot of evidence that in their sophomore seasons either of these two would have been able to pick up the slack that Darnell initiated. Here’s how the season would have likely ended up.


Assuming Darnell went down in the second half of the IU contest, the ‘Cats would have hung on to beat the Hoosiers, 28-10. But the loss of such an offensive force would have put more strain mentally and physically on the Wildcats. Steve Schnur would have to do more with his arm than simply manage the games and limit mistakes. He would have to take more risks- not really his forte.


The Michigan game would have been too much with this added pressure on the offense and the ‘Cat’s simply wouldn’t have been able to put up the same performance they did that October day: Wolverines win 21-10.


The disappointment from not performing in Ann Arbor may have had a hangover effect on the boys in Purple. NU struggled in that game (in reality) until Darnell turned it on in the second half as it was, so without him (in this hypothetical) proved to be an obstacle the ‘Cats couldn’t hurdle. Sam Valenzisi missed a long 58 yard FG late in the game as the ‘Cats dropped a heart-breaker, 19-17.


Now sitting at 3-3, Northwestern went into their Homecoming against an inconsistent Wisconsin team. The Wildcats, hitting on all cylinders, gave the home crowd a reason to cheer once again and set their sights on the postseason, beating the Badgers 27-6 on a rainy day in Evanston.


The following week, the Wildcat offense faced one another tough defense, with the trio of Illinois linebackers (Hardy, Rice, Holocek). It came close, as this game but the Illini got the best of the Wildcats, making a goal line late in the 4th quarter, topping the ‘Cats, 20-16.


At 4-4, the Penn State game was not nationally televised and played at noon eastern time instead. The Nittany Lions were sleeping through most of the game but made a roar (sorry for the pun) in the second half, kicking the Wildcats back below the Mendoza line with a 31-10 outcome.


The good news is the Wildcats ended the year with two victories over Iowa (27-13) and Purdue (30-3). With those victories, they ended with a 6-5 record overall and 4-4 in the conference, putting them in a 6th place finish behind Ohio State, Michigan, Penn State, Illinois and Michigan State. They accepted a bid to the Sun Bowl to play Washington. In that game, the defense stepped up and shut down a mid-level Huskies offense and get their second ever bowl victory in school history. The front seven and some periodic safety blitzes put pressure on Damon Huard, causing errant throws and a few fumbles that the opportunistic ‘Cats defense pounced on.


Adrian Autry finished with just under 900 yards rushing, while Leary and FBs Levelle Brown peppered some additional relief. FB Matt Hartl became an even bigger part of the offense (primarily in the passing game) and the defense, having to be on the field more was not as dominant as they were in the real ’95 season, but still, they led the way toward the program’s first bowl berth and bowl win since ’49.
 
Historic Hypothetical:
If Darnell Autry got injured during the 1995 season



We all loved the 1995 season. It was clearly the turning point of Northwestern football. Imagine this scenario, though. During the 4th game of the season against Indiana, the Heisman finalist injures his leg and is done for the season. Northwestern is forced to turn to sophomores Adrian Autry (no relation) and Faraji Leary. Adrian Autry averaged 3.7 yards per carry and Leary 3.3 but mostly in mop up time. There wasn’t a lot of evidence that in their sophomore seasons either of these two would have been able to pick up the slack that Darnell initiated. Here’s how the season would have likely ended up.


Assuming Darnell went down in the second half of the IU contest, the ‘Cats would have hung on to beat the Hoosiers, 28-10. But the loss of such an offensive force would have put more strain mentally and physically on the Wildcats. Steve Schnur would have to do more with his arm than simply manage the games and limit mistakes. He would have to take more risks- not really his forte.


The Michigan game would have been too much with this added pressure on the offense and the ‘Cat’s simply wouldn’t have been able to put up the same performance they did that October day: Wolverines win 21-10.


The disappointment from not performing in Ann Arbor may have had a hangover effect on the boys in Purple. NU struggled in that game (in reality) until Darnell turned it on in the second half as it was, so without him (in this hypothetical) proved to be an obstacle the ‘Cats couldn’t hurdle. Sam Valenzisi missed a long 58 yard FG late in the game as the ‘Cats dropped a heart-breaker, 19-17.


Now sitting at 3-3, Northwestern went into their Homecoming against an inconsistent Wisconsin team. The Wildcats, hitting on all cylinders, gave the home crowd a reason to cheer once again and set their sights on the postseason, beating the Badgers 27-6 on a rainy day in Evanston.


The following week, the Wildcat offense faced one another tough defense, with the trio of Illinois linebackers (Hardy, Rice, Holocek). It came close, as this game but the Illini got the best of the Wildcats, making a goal line late in the 4th quarter, topping the ‘Cats, 20-16.


At 4-4, the Penn State game was not nationally televised and played at noon eastern time instead. The Nittany Lions were sleeping through most of the game but made a roar (sorry for the pun) in the second half, kicking the Wildcats back below the Mendoza line with a 31-10 outcome.


The good news is the Wildcats ended the year with two victories over Iowa (27-13) and Purdue (30-3). With those victories, they ended with a 6-5 record overall and 4-4 in the conference, putting them in a 6th place finish behind Ohio State, Michigan, Penn State, Illinois and Michigan State. They accepted a bid to the Sun Bowl to play Washington. In that game, the defense stepped up and shut down a mid-level Huskies offense and get their second ever bowl victory in school history. The front seven and some periodic safety blitzes put pressure on Damon Huard, causing errant throws and a few fumbles that the opportunistic ‘Cats defense pounced on.


Adrian Autry finished with just under 900 yards rushing, while Leary and FBs Levelle Brown peppered some additional relief. FB Matt Hartl became an even bigger part of the offense (primarily in the passing game) and the defense, having to be on the field more was not as dominant as they were in the real ’95 season, but still, they led the way toward the program’s first bowl berth and bowl win since ’49.

What's the point of this?
 
Just an interesting read. Also to point out just how valuable Darnell was to that team.
A far more interesting "what if?": Lou Saban comes down with phlebitis in 1955 and appoints George Steinbrenner as head coach. He names Billy Martin as his offensive coordinator. Billy gets into a brawl at the Pancake House and is fired by Steinbrenner days before Phil Wrigley names George as the Cubs' third base coach, whereupon Bo Schembechler is elevated to head football coach at NU.
 
Historic Hypothetical:
If Darnell Autry got injured during the 1995 season



We all loved the 1995 season. It was clearly the turning point of Northwestern football. Imagine this scenario, though. During the 4th game of the season against Indiana, the Heisman finalist injures his leg and is done for the season. Northwestern is forced to turn to sophomores Adrian Autry (no relation) and Faraji Leary. Adrian Autry averaged 3.7 yards per carry and Leary 3.3 but mostly in mop up time. There wasn’t a lot of evidence that in their sophomore seasons either of these two would have been able to pick up the slack that Darnell initiated. Here’s how the season would have likely ended up.


Assuming Darnell went down in the second half of the IU contest, the ‘Cats would have hung on to beat the Hoosiers, 28-10. But the loss of such an offensive force would have put more strain mentally and physically on the Wildcats. Steve Schnur would have to do more with his arm than simply manage the games and limit mistakes. He would have to take more risks- not really his forte.


The Michigan game would have been too much with this added pressure on the offense and the ‘Cat’s simply wouldn’t have been able to put up the same performance they did that October day: Wolverines win 21-10.


The disappointment from not performing in Ann Arbor may have had a hangover effect on the boys in Purple. NU struggled in that game (in reality) until Darnell turned it on in the second half as it was, so without him (in this hypothetical) proved to be an obstacle the ‘Cats couldn’t hurdle. Sam Valenzisi missed a long 58 yard FG late in the game as the ‘Cats dropped a heart-breaker, 19-17.


Now sitting at 3-3, Northwestern went into their Homecoming against an inconsistent Wisconsin team. The Wildcats, hitting on all cylinders, gave the home crowd a reason to cheer once again and set their sights on the postseason, beating the Badgers 27-6 on a rainy day in Evanston.


The following week, the Wildcat offense faced one another tough defense, with the trio of Illinois linebackers (Hardy, Rice, Holocek). It came close, as this game but the Illini got the best of the Wildcats, making a goal line late in the 4th quarter, topping the ‘Cats, 20-16.


At 4-4, the Penn State game was not nationally televised and played at noon eastern time instead. The Nittany Lions were sleeping through most of the game but made a roar (sorry for the pun) in the second half, kicking the Wildcats back below the Mendoza line with a 31-10 outcome.


The good news is the Wildcats ended the year with two victories over Iowa (27-13) and Purdue (30-3). With those victories, they ended with a 6-5 record overall and 4-4 in the conference, putting them in a 6th place finish behind Ohio State, Michigan, Penn State, Illinois and Michigan State. They accepted a bid to the Sun Bowl to play Washington. In that game, the defense stepped up and shut down a mid-level Huskies offense and get their second ever bowl victory in school history. The front seven and some periodic safety blitzes put pressure on Damon Huard, causing errant throws and a few fumbles that the opportunistic ‘Cats defense pounced on.


Adrian Autry finished with just under 900 yards rushing, while Leary and FBs Levelle Brown peppered some additional relief. FB Matt Hartl became an even bigger part of the offense (primarily in the passing game) and the defense, having to be on the field more was not as dominant as they were in the real ’95 season, but still, they led the way toward the program’s first bowl berth and bowl win since ’49.
As a historian I ask you please to try not to combine "history" and "hypothetical" in any way, shape, or form. It is more irritating than "historical fiction", which is nothing more than literature for idiots. Please - I cannot take this stuff - it is not interesting, only inane. We all know what happened in '95 - enjoy the memories.
 
Wow- okay. I am a historian as well and always prefer the historic to the hypothetical. However as we sit in the downtime, it was just something to help appreciate the great memories of '95 and the importance of DA. Still, point respected.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hungry Jack
Chappy, a better exercise and more interesting read for me would be to project how the 2009-10 bball team became the first NU men's team to make the NCAA tournament, not the 2016-7 team, when Kevin Coble did NOT miss the season with a Lisfranc fracture, and instead teamed up Shurna, Juice and co. to lead the Cats to The Dance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NUCat320
As a historian I ask you please to try not to combine "history" and "hypothetical" in any way, shape, or form. It is more irritating than "historical fiction", which is nothing more than literature for idiots. Please - I cannot take this stuff - it is not interesting, only inane. We all know what happened in '95 - enjoy the memories.
Is there a preferable term, or are you just angry about those darn kids and your beautiful lawn?
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChappyCat
Chappy, a better exercise and more interesting read for me would be to project how the 2009-10 bball team became the first NU men's team to make the NCAA tournament, not the 2016-7 team, when Kevin Coble did NOT miss the season with a Lisfranc fracture, and instead teamed up Shurna, Juice and co. to lead the Cats to The Dance.

And complete fantasy. There is no scenario that I could envision NU going to the NCAA's under Comedy.
 
Thanks for reminding me of my all-time favorite Cats nickname. Before Persa-Strong and JJTBC, we had "no relation"

He was called that all the time in the media
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChappyCat
Historic Hypothetical:
If Darnell Autry got injured during the 1995 season



We all loved the 1995 season. It was clearly the turning point of Northwestern football. Imagine this scenario, though. During the 4th game of the season against Indiana, the Heisman finalist injures his leg and is done for the season. Northwestern is forced to turn to sophomores Adrian Autry (no relation) and Faraji Leary. Adrian Autry averaged 3.7 yards per carry and Leary 3.3 but mostly in mop up time. There wasn’t a lot of evidence that in their sophomore seasons either of these two would have been able to pick up the slack that Darnell initiated. Here’s how the season would have likely ended up.


Assuming Darnell went down in the second half of the IU contest, the ‘Cats would have hung on to beat the Hoosiers, 28-10. But the loss of such an offensive force would have put more strain mentally and physically on the Wildcats. Steve Schnur would have to do more with his arm than simply manage the games and limit mistakes. He would have to take more risks- not really his forte.


The Michigan game would have been too much with this added pressure on the offense and the ‘Cat’s simply wouldn’t have been able to put up the same performance they did that October day: Wolverines win 21-10.


The disappointment from not performing in Ann Arbor may have had a hangover effect on the boys in Purple. NU struggled in that game (in reality) until Darnell turned it on in the second half as it was, so without him (in this hypothetical) proved to be an obstacle the ‘Cats couldn’t hurdle. Sam Valenzisi missed a long 58 yard FG late in the game as the ‘Cats dropped a heart-breaker, 19-17.


Now sitting at 3-3, Northwestern went into their Homecoming against an inconsistent Wisconsin team. The Wildcats, hitting on all cylinders, gave the home crowd a reason to cheer once again and set their sights on the postseason, beating the Badgers 27-6 on a rainy day in Evanston.


The following week, the Wildcat offense faced one another tough defense, with the trio of Illinois linebackers (Hardy, Rice, Holocek). It came close, as this game but the Illini got the best of the Wildcats, making a goal line late in the 4th quarter, topping the ‘Cats, 20-16.


At 4-4, the Penn State game was not nationally televised and played at noon eastern time instead. The Nittany Lions were sleeping through most of the game but made a roar (sorry for the pun) in the second half, kicking the Wildcats back below the Mendoza line with a 31-10 outcome.


The good news is the Wildcats ended the year with two victories over Iowa (27-13) and Purdue (30-3). With those victories, they ended with a 6-5 record overall and 4-4 in the conference, putting them in a 6th place finish behind Ohio State, Michigan, Penn State, Illinois and Michigan State. They accepted a bid to the Sun Bowl to play Washington. In that game, the defense stepped up and shut down a mid-level Huskies offense and get their second ever bowl victory in school history. The front seven and some periodic safety blitzes put pressure on Damon Huard, causing errant throws and a few fumbles that the opportunistic ‘Cats defense pounced on.


Adrian Autry finished with just under 900 yards rushing, while Leary and FBs Levelle Brown peppered some additional relief. FB Matt Hartl became an even bigger part of the offense (primarily in the passing game) and the defense, having to be on the field more was not as dominant as they were in the real ’95 season, but still, they led the way toward the program’s first bowl berth and bowl win since ’49.


Okay, I'll bite. Your scenario is plausible, although our opinions differ on the consequences.

I think the Cats still win the Michigan game - they were going to win regardless of adversity (see e.g., having a backup QB with limited experience stand in for Schnur at a crucial moment).

No hangover, therefore, occurred in the subsequent game or rippled deeper in the schedule. I think, instead, Autry's loss would further galvanize the team a la post Miami of Ohio defeat. And giving the Butterfly Effect its full due, Autry's absence would significantly change the pace and complexion of later games, so that Fitz doesn't break his leg on that Iowa running play and Sam Valenzisi doesn't injure himself celebrating a late score.

I think the Cats would likely have run the table, including prevailing at the Rose Bowl game - the NCAA would have DQ'd Keyshawn and the refs would have ruled Musso was down during his "fumble."
 
Just an interesting read. Also to point out just how valuable Darnell was to that team.

Darnell was a good player, but you underrate the role of NU's excellent OL and defensive dominance to winning games.

Adrian was a good football player too.
 
Okay, I'll bite. Your scenario is plausible, although our opinions differ on the consequences.

I think the Cats still win the Michigan game - they were going to win regardless of adversity (see e.g., having a backup QB with limited experience stand in for Schnur at a crucial moment).

No hangover, therefore, occurred in the subsequent game or rippled deeper in the schedule. I think, instead, Autry's loss would further galvanize the team a la post Miami of Ohio defeat. And giving the Butterfly Effect its full due, Autry's absence would significantly change the pace and complexion of later games, so that Fitz doesn't break his leg on that Iowa running play and Sam Valenzisi doesn't injure himself celebrating a late score.

I think the Cats would likely have run the table, including prevailing at the Rose Bowl game - the NCAA would have DQ'd Keyshawn and the refs would have ruled Musso was down during his "fumble."

Instead of spending the day tackling Darnell Autry for losses, Michigan would have spent the day tackling Adrian Autry for losses.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT