ADVERTISEMENT

How many more wins does it take?

hdhntr1

Well-Known Member
Gold Member
Sep 6, 2006
34,564
7,756
113
To get to NIT or Dance.. I say 7 for NIT and 8 for Dance. Total BIG wins including BTT being 9 for NIT and 10 for Dance. This assumes our OOC schedule is viewed more favorably than last year. Best way to get there is to start by taking care of business tonight
 
Last edited:
Including or excluding BTT?
including. Ten wins would mean 10-8 in season and 0-1 BTT, 9-9 in conference plus 1-1 in BTT or 8-19 and at least two BTT wins. NIT would require one less win. And it is just my guess what it would take. WHAT say others?
 
including. Ten wins would mean 10-8 in season and 0-1 BTT, 9-9 in conference plus 1-1 in BTT or 8-19 and at least two BTT wins. NIT would require one less win. And it is just my guess what it would take. WHAT say others?

10-8 in conference and 0-1 in BTT gets us to 21-11 for the season. Definite bubble range type record. Teams in the BIG will be bunched together at or near a .500 conference regular season record. So lots of hair splitting will occur by the committee. There will be plusses and minuses for the Cats. Close early season losses to @Butler and ND in NYC will actually be a plus. Early exit in the BTT not good at all. To be confident about dancing, I think we need to get an upset or 2, and get to 23 wins...preferably with a strong finish to the end of the season. So many variables in play. But 23 wins and we're in, 22 wins should get us in and 21 wins will have a lot of people praying.

GOUNUII
 
i think nu needs 11-7 in conference or 10-8 with two wins in B10 tourney for NCAA. who cares about NIT?
 
  • Like
Reactions: phatcat
i think nu needs 11-7 in conference or 10-8 with two wins in B10 tourney for NCAA. who cares about NIT?
Since the start of conference season my target formula has been 10 + 1. So need to go 7-6 the rest of the way now... nice win tonight! 3 wins on the card out of the first 5 rounds of the fight.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ColumbusCatFan1
10-8 in conference and 0-1 in BTT gets us to 21-11 for the season. Definite bubble range type record. Teams in the BIG will be bunched together at or near a .500 conference regular season record. So lots of hair splitting will occur by the committee. There will be plusses and minuses for the Cats. Close early season losses to @Butler and ND in NYC will actually be a plus. Early exit in the BTT not good at all. To be confident about dancing, I think we need to get an upset or 2, and get to 23 wins...preferably with a strong finish to the end of the season. So many variables in play. But 23 wins and we're in, 22 wins should get us in and 21 wins will have a lot of people praying.

GOUNUII
WI am not sure with 10-8 that a first round exit will be seen as that bad as you think. Basically the BIG, while not as tough at the top is stronger overall and likely to get more than last years 7 teams in. The 8th team was Mich (with a 10-8 record) But the conference was considered weak so with a couple BTT wins they were invited. Just feel that the conference will be rated stronger this year so wins in conference will have more weight plus our OOC schedule is better.
 
Last edited:
WI am not sure with 10-8 that a first round exit will be seen as that bad as you think. Wouldn't they have a first round bye and have to go up against someone ranked higher?.
Nah, I think 10-8 would get us the 5 6 or 7 seed. So we would play the 10, 11/14 winner, or 12/13 winner. If we drop that it wouldn't be great. If we somehow managed to get a double bye in the top 4 teams, then losing to a 5,6 ish team wouldn't be so bad.. then again if we are the 3 or 4 seed in the BTT we hopefully wouldn't be on the bubble.
 
Nah, I think 10-8 would get us the 5 6 or 7 seed. So we would play the 10, 11/14 winner, or 12/13 winner. If we drop that it wouldn't be great. If we somehow managed to get a double bye in the top 4 teams, then losing to a 5,6 ish team wouldn't be so bad.. then again if we are the 3 or 4 seed in the BTT we hopefully wouldn't be on the bubble.
I checked last year. 10-8 was 8th (Michigan) and they beat us in the 8-9 game. 7 was OSU with an 11-7 record and they ended up in the NIT even after winning one game in BTT. But the conference was considered pretty weak overall. Just saying, it is more balanced this year than any time I can remember and that added strength should mean more invites.
 
I checked last year. 10-8 was 8th (Michigan) and they beat us in the 8-9 game. 7 was OSU with an 11-7 record and they ended up in the NIT even after winning one game in BTT. But the conference was considered pretty weak overall. Just saying, it is more balanced this year than any time I can remember and that added strength should mean more invites.
Yeah, but logically and statistically speaking, having the 8th team out of 14 be above .500 is an aberration. Last year's specific results don't really mean much for the distribution of seeds relative to records (ignoring team names). Outside of possible outliers, this distribution of assignments (particularly in the middle) is close to random, especially across years. It was mostly because the bottom 2 teams were 1-17 and 2-16 last year, while the top 2 were 15-3 and 13-5 (a combined difference of 5 wins, which transferred itself onto the 3-8 seeds).

While it looks like Rutgers will be bad again this year, I don't think they are as hopeless as last year... and Minny has clearly improved. I think if there's a cluster of teams this year it's more likely to be in the 8-10 to 10-8 range, rather than in the 10-8 to 12-6 range (6 teams) as it was last year, which led to the asymmetric distribution.
 
I think we need to get six Big Ten wins by the end of January to put ourselves in position for a tougher February. That would mean three of the following four: Iowa, @OSU, Nebraska, Indiana. Tough, but doable.
 
i think nu needs 11-7 in conference or 10-8 with two wins in B10 tourney for NCAA. who cares about NIT?
Your scenerio is the path. Only in years when the BIG is really talented would it be possible with only 10 wins.
The best key to us achieving our goals is our away record, which is currently 3-1. Stay healthy.
 
Your scenerio is the path. Only in years when the BIG is really talented would it be possible with only 10 wins.
The best key to us achieving our goals is our away record, which is currently 3-1. Stay healthy.
In 2015, an IN team that went 9-9 in conference went to the dance but a 9-9 IL did not. They won their 10th game in the BTT beating us and lost the next round. IL lost their 1st round game In 2014, with only 12 teams, a 9-9 Iowa went to the dance. They never had the tenth win as they lost to us in BTT. In 2013, a 9-9 IA did not go even with a 10th win in BTT but an 8-10 IL (9th win in BTT) and and 8-10 MN with no BTT win went to the dance. In 2012 no 9-9 teamsbut every one with 10-8 or above went and 8-10 teams all went to NIT. In 2011, four 9-9 teams all went. In 2010, one 10-8 team did not go (NIT for IL) but a 9-9 MN went.

So in general, a 10-8 team not going is the exception as in the tim looked at all but one went. And most 9-9 teams and even some 8-10 teams went. So generally the BIG is seen as strong enough and 10 wins is enough. Exceptions? A couple but they are exceptions.
 
Since the start of conference season my target formula has been 10 + 1. So need to go 7-6 the rest of the way now... nice win tonight! 3 wins on the card out of the first 5 rounds of the fight.

This exercise is challenging for many reasons (bid thieves, conference strength, bubble peers, etc) but if I had to choose a number, I would line up with you, Ricko. 10-8; 1-1 BTT.

One "small" caveat though. The Cats' will need to notch at least one top 25 RPI victory along the way, preferably on the road.

There will plenty of opportunities for top 50/100 wins as the season moves forward (the Cats' already have several), but when NU hoops has previously been in the mix for the elusive NCAA bid (08-09 & 11-12) they've knocked off at least one of the big boys in conference.

Bagging a big fish or two between now and March will do wonders for the tournament resume.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ricko654321
In 2015, an IN team that went 9-9 in conference went to the dance but a 9-9 IL did not. They won their 10th game in the BTT beating us and lost the next round. IL lost their 1st round game In 2014, with only 12 teams, a 9-9 Iowa went to the dance. They never had the tenth win as they lost to us in BTT. In 2013, a 9-9 IA did not go even with a 10th win in BTT but an 8-10 IL (9th win in BTT) and and 8-10 MN with no BTT win went to the dance. In 2012 no 9-9 teamsbut every one with 10-8 or above went and 8-10 teams all went to NIT. In 2011, four 9-9 teams all went. In 2010, one 10-8 team did not go (NIT for IL) but a 9-9 MN went.

So in general, a 10-8 team not going is the exception as in the tim looked at all but one went. And most 9-9 teams and even some 8-10 teams went. So generally the BIG is seen as strong enough and 10 wins is enough. Exceptions? A couple but they are exceptions.
While that is all true, the 10 win threshold was based on how competitive the conference was/is. My opinion is that the conference really is down this year. So 10 wins, in my opinion, isnt going to make it for some teams. If dayton rebounds then that may help. We need to beat purdue or someone solid. The problem is that only msu seems consistent but we dont play them again. Beating rutgers, nebraska, illinois all twice and beating osu and psu once, isnt going to cut it unless we beat wisconsin and purdue or sweep iowa. The 4 best teams in the big are msu minny purdue. We are 0-2 right now. Indiana is on a terrible slide after having a good ooc run but they seem to be falling.
 
One "small" caveat though. The Cats' will need to notch at least one top 25 RPI victory along the way, preferably on the road..

Going to be difficult. Right now, there are zero remaining teams with a top 25 RPI on the NU schedule. NU has lost to Minny and MSU. UMD (28) and PU (39) would be great from an RPI and quality win perspectives. Doesn't look like NU will have more than say 1 win against a top 25 RPI.
 
This is always a fun site: RPI Forecast. A few days ago, NU was projected to go 20-11, now it's 21-10 (the away game against Illinois moved past 50%). It's a nice way to look at the schedule and figure out where the wins are coming. NU is projected to finish with an RPI of 52 (I think it was 56 yesterday).

They are projected to go 2-2 in their next four games, but the two losses are considered > 40% chance of winning. Go 4-0 there going into the Purdue game, and then February gets really interesting.
 
This exercise is challenging for many reasons (bid thieves, conference strength, bubble peers, etc) but if I had to choose a number, I would line up with you, Ricko. 10-8; 1-1 BTT.

One "small" caveat though. The Cats' will need to notch at least one top 25 RPI victory along the way, preferably on the road.

There will plenty of opportunities for top 50/100 wins as the season moves forward (the Cats' already have several), but when NU hoops has previously been in the mix for the elusive NCAA bid (08-09 & 11-12) they've knocked off at least one of the big boys in conference.

Bagging a big fish or two between now and March will do wonders for the tournament resume.
Yeah - to be clear 10 + 1 is my target, but I agree there are lots of moving targets and the picture could certainly change. I don't think that guarantees us in by any means, but I think it puts us on the right side of the bubble in most cases.

A top 25 win would be nice, but as someone else pointed out below, there aren't a ton of top 25 teams in conference this year. In terms of actual team quality (not rankings), I think the B1G doesn't have any top 10 teams, but I think we probably have 8 or 9 that are 11-50. Wiscy, Purdue, Minny, MSU, MD, NU, Mich, Indy, at least as of right now. IL and IA have shown flashes but inconsistent. Neb OSU PSU out for now, and Rutgers obviously wayyy out.

My guess is ~4 of those 9 will end up in the back half of the reg season top 25 (AP)- Wiscy and Purdue almost certainly, then maybe 2 out of MSU, MD, Minny. Whether those teams are in the top 25 of RPI or Ken Pom or who knows (the committee will prob have all those numbers in front of them), I think the key is that we end up with a handful of wins over NCAA Tourney teams - our quality wins will likely manifest itself with a number of top 50 W's rather than 1-2 signature marquee wins.
 
Don't forget all those other big 10 teams are also going to struggle getting top 25 wins.
 
Don't forget all those other big 10 teams are also going to struggle getting top 25 wins.
Yep exactly. All of us are going to have lots of top 50 wins, but not many top 25 wins. No single category matters that much by itself, it's all of it together.
 
Minnesota's visit to the top 25 is likely to end today. They are struggling at Penn State late in the 2nd half, on the heels of getting blown out in their previous game.
 
Going to be difficult. Right now, there are zero remaining teams with a top 25 RPI on the NU schedule. NU has lost to Minny and MSU. UMD (28) and PU (39) would be great from an RPI and quality win perspectives. Doesn't look like NU will have more than say 1 win against a top 25 RPI.

A good point that really hits on the general chaos/depth of the conference this year and yet another reason it's hard to make predictions at this point.

If I had to guess, I'd say MSU, Purdue,
and Wisconsin will finish in the RPI top 25, with Maryland possibly sneaking in. All these opponents are "name brands" and even though there will plenty of chances to boast the resume w top 50-100 wins, I think just one win from this group will be go along way to getting the Cats' in the dance.
 
Last edited:
A good point that really hits on the general chaos/depth of the conference this year and yet another reason it's hard to make predictions at this point.

If I had to guess, I'd say MSU, Purdue,
and Wisconsin will finish in the RPI top 25, with Maryland possibly sneaking in. All these opponents are "name brands" and even though there will plenty of chances to boast the resume w top 50-100 wins, I think just one win from this group will be go along way to getting the Cats' in the dance.

I'd add Indiana to that list. Team that talented will figure it out, imo. And their Kenpom is only #26
 
I want to see us get hot and go on an 8 game winning streak right now and put an end to this NCAA tournament qualifying hand-wringing, low expectations crap. That's what the football team did in 1995. Why not basketball this year. Buckle up your chin straps!
 
Last edited:
I want to see us get hot and go on an 8 game winning streak right now and put an end to this NCAA tournament qualifying hand-wringing, low expectations crap. That's what the football team did in 1995. Why not basketball this year.“It’s telling, I’m afraid, that Donald Trump treats Vladimir Putin with more respect than he does John Lewis. Buckle up your chin straps!

John Lewis doesn't command the #2 military in the world, or have the ability to send Nukes to LA and New York City.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Inovacat
LOL! I guess an edit to a facebook rant got pasted into my basketball post. Vlad's coming. He's going to pop out of a huge inaugural cake with a Supersoaker.
 
While that is all true, the 10 win threshold was based on how competitive the conference was/is. My opinion is that the conference really is down this year. So 10 wins, in my opinion, isnt going to make it for some teams. If dayton rebounds then that may help. We need to beat purdue or someone solid. The problem is that only msu seems consistent but we dont play them again. Beating rutgers, nebraska, illinois all twice and beating osu and psu once, isnt going to cut it unless we beat wisconsin and purdue or sweep iowa. The 4 best teams in the big are msu minny purdue. We are 0-2 right now. Indiana is on a terrible slide after having a good ooc run but they seem to be falling.
There are not the top teams but the rest of the conference is as strong and competitive as I have seen it. The conference is very competitive this year.
 
There are not the top teams but the rest of the conference is as strong and competitive as I have seen it. The conference is very competitive this year.
Absolutely right. The BTT figures to be the most entertaining one we've seen.
 
Y'all are counting wins and I'm over here thinking that's there's no reason we can't finish in the top three of the conference.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NU Houston
Y'all are counting wins and I'm over here thinking that's there's no reason we can't finish in the top three of the conference.

If we can win next week in Columbus, we'll be a serious contender.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT