ADVERTISEMENT

Residents worry Northwestern’s new Ryan Field proposal could turn Evanston into Wrigleyville

Sheffielder

Well-Known Member
Gold Member
Sep 1, 2004
9,226
2,238
113
By Corey Schmidt
Pioneer Press

Nov 07, 2022 at 2:20 pm

Evanston residents expressed concern at a recent meeting hosted by City Councilmember Eleanor Revelle about how Northwestern’s new Ryan Field proposal could impact the area’s culture, saying it could resemble Chicago’s Wrigleyville neighborhood.

Wrigleyville is known for its Cubs games and bar scene and residents are concerned that by allowing more events and concerts at the field that the surrounding neighborhood will be disrupted.

A proposed text amendment is expected to expand the venue’s hosting privileges to 12 community and cultural events — including concerts, allow external event sponsors, and a 25,000-person capacity increase. Current policy allows the stadium to host a maximum of seven community events per year with a 10,000-person capacity, according to a Northwestern University presentation.

“Currently, we have a handful of football games a year that have 35,000 or more fans and you’re proposing to have (a total of 12 additional events) with 35,000 people. At some point, (there is) a point where a line is crossed and the neighborhood changes,” resident John Labbe said. “I mean Wrigley Field is a different type of stadium, different type of neighborhood.”

Northwestern’s Executive Director of Neighborhood and Community Relations Dave Davis said the project will not significantly impact the area’s culture because events will primarily be held during certain times of the year.

“It’s not going to be a dome, it is going to be a canopied facility and so (events won’t be held year-round, it will be) over about a seven-month time frame,” Davis said. “(At) 12 events, we’re looking at one or maybe two events per month.”

Despite Davis’ reassurance, residents are worried about how concerts could disturb nearby residents. Northwestern’s Project Manager Steven Himes, who also worked on the 2018 Welsh-Ryan Arena renovation, said the stadium’s design will help contain noise.

“The stadium would have partial facades that are partially enclosed on its vertical surfaces — not entirely but partially — and then there is a 360 degrees canopy extending from the perimeter over the seating bowl that will help reflect sound into the stadium to contain that sound,” Himes said.

Ryan Field currently has a 47,130-person capacity for all events. This new stadium would put it at 35,000 for all events, which is roughly 15,000 below the next smallest Big Ten Conference stadium.

The text amendment has various obstacles to navigate before gaining city approval. Northwestern will submit an application to city staff to be analyzed and get approved to appear before City Council by both the Land Use Commission and the Planning and Development Committee, according to a Northwestern University presentation. Once approved by those two bodies, it moves on to City Council.

Public comment will be available throughout the process at each step.

The text amendment process is expected to begin in winter 2022 and wrap up during 2023, according to Northwestern’s anticipated timeline.

Northwestern will submit a planned development application, the presentation showed. City staff will review the proposed plans to determine what city code variations will be required. After city analysis, a projected and design review will take place where city staff will provide further comments on the proposed project. It will then appear before the Land Use Commission and Planning and Development Committee before making it to City Council. The anticipated budget outlines this process beginning in winter 2022 to extend through summer 2023 with public input being heard by both committees and City Council.

Northwestern’s presentation said the university wants to enhance the event-going experience for its visitors through concessions and alcohol sales. This will require an updated liquor license request to be authorized by the city. The license will go through the Liquor Control Board, Administration and Public Works Committee and City Council with public input allowed by all three entities, according to the presentation.

“One of the areas we’re looking to improve is providing our guests with a better food and beverage and concessions experience,” Denee Barracato, deputy director of athletics at Northwestern, said. “Alcohol and the offering of alcohol in all of our spaces is an area we intend to improve not just for our premium ticket holders but really all fans in general admission seating.”

Revelle plans to hold a series of Ryan Field meetings that will be advertised in the 7th Ward newsletter.

Corey Schmidt is a freelance reporter with Pioneer Press.
 
I mean, if you're spending $800 million to build a state of the art luxury facility... it does make sense to use a lot more than just 7 times a year outside of football games.

Makes sense that they'd want to go from 7 events of 10000 to 12 events of 35000. It's a big change, but the stadium's going to provide an incredible experience for pretty much any other style of event whether concerts or otherwise.
 
Last edited:
They should look at it as a positive. One of the coolest dinners I ever had was at my brother's place in Barcelona. We were eating on his balcony and U2 was playing a concert at the Olympic stadium on top of the hill. They had their speakers blasted so loud, you could hear them clear as day all over the city. We basically got a free evening concert with our dinner without leaving the confines of (my brother's) home.
 
Here we go. I don’t think a new NU stadium with 18-20 large events is comparable to 80 home Cubs games, and the bar-going age demographic in Wrigleyville will never be that of Central and Linden.
That's the other thing, Wrigleyville comparison is way off base when you think about the sheer number of Cubs games.

Most of the additional Ryan Field events will be one offs and concerts that will trend towards various demographics, some that are much younger or older.

This isn't going to dramatically change the scope of what the neighborhood looks like, and given reduced capacity and design choices for containing noise/light, the concerns are adequately dealt with..
 
They should look at it as a positive. One of the coolest dinners I ever had was at my brother's place in Barcelona. We were eating on his balcony and U2 was playing a concert at the Olympic stadium on top of the hill. They had their speakers blasted so loud, you could hear them clear as day all over the city. We basically got a free evening concert with our dinner without leaving the confines of (my brother's) home.
I agree that if I got a free concert by U2 regularly, that would be great, but there are lots of concerts I would not want to listen to for 10 seconds.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IGNORE2
That's the other thing, Wrigleyville comparison is way off base when you think about the sheer number of Cubs games.

Most of the additional Ryan Field events will be one offs and concerts that will trend towards various demographics, some that are much younger or older.

This isn't going to dramatically change the scope of what the neighborhood looks like, and given reduced capacity and design choices for containing noise/light, the concerns are adequately dealt with..
The Wrigleyville comparison is ludicrous on its face and should not be humored for even a second, though it will of course be.

My plan of action to demonstrate that a new, smaller stadium should lead to no more problems problems than the current one will to be urinate against residents’ homes during the remaining games at the current stadium. That should help prove that a new venue will not be inherently worse.
 
I’m disappointed. Where’s all the comments regarding drunken orgies and public drug use? Isn’t anyone thinking, ‘What about the children?’
 
  • Like
Reactions: IGNORE2
Oh, for Pete's sake, there is a stadium there now. What could change--Mustard's becomes a national chain and builds a giant beer garden for the masses to enjoy brats and beer? This knee-jerk is no different than Evanston being a dry town for more than half a century.
 
So one guy is worried it's going to "turn into Wrigleyville", whatever the hell that means.

This is a nothing-burger of a story. This stadium will be approved, although it may require a little something from NU to appea$e the city of Evanston.
 
No one mentioned public defecation on residents lawns???? Drunken concert goers wiping their asses on the door knobs of private citizens front doors??? I am surprised.....
 
No one mentioned public defecation on residents lawns???? Drunken concert goers wiping their asses on the door knobs of private citizens front doors??? I am surprised.....
Northwestern students defecate on lawns? So much for top 10, they accept students who will s*** wherever they want? Sounds like Kellogg.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT