ADVERTISEMENT

FB RECRUITING Northwestern offers Tennessee state champ in 2026 OT Jacob Crow


I talked to 2026 OT offer Jacob Crow about his dominant season for Tennessee state power Alcoa, his offer from NU, and more.

Disappointment with Jim Phillips


I know some of you will disagree with me, but I think this is BS.

“I’m up for anything that can help get us somewhere.” Says the President of a Multi, Multi Million Dollar organization. Aren’t you the perso. supposed to “get us somewhere”?

And Jim Phillips, our outstanding former Athletic Director, really misses the mark:

“National Standard in Name, Image, and Likeness” - Other than a Federal Minimum Wage what earthly reason is there for Congress or some agency to create eligibility of compensation standards? There is none.

“A piecemeal project that has undermined college sports” - You mean the piecemeal project of doing everything possible to not admit what has been blatantly obvious for decades: Roster members of revenue college sports teams are employees in an extraordinarily large and lucrative business.”

“A race to the bottom” - I have no earthly idea what that means. The only thing that has been a race is all of our consciousness realizing just how dramatically underpaid players wearing college jerseys have been in recent decades.

“We need some legal protection.” - Why? What the hell? Compensate your employees through individual or collectively bargained agreements in conformance with the existing labor laws. What is so hard about that?

“A reaffirmation that these are student-athletes” - If you are reading this board, you know of Taylor Branch’s fine work illuminating the history of this phrase. Saying something (and demanding your corporate media partners say the same thing) does not make it a legally binding term.

I totally get it. I enjoyed college sports for seeing individuals matriculate to my beloved alma mater, grow into adults, become better players before our eyes, and graduate…forging a bond recognized over time and location.

But, let us recognize that long before players started getting compensated, it was the adults…university administrators, who determined that this was a big business and chasing revenue was the goal. Full stop.

The current predicament we are in bears a direct relationship to those decisions made consistently, constantly toward revenue maximization over multiple decades.

Spare me the anguish for the lost romance of old-timey college sports

New NIL commission coming?

I have no doubt many here would agree because it is no longer really "college" sports to them. But, we can look forward to the center from Missouri snapping to the QB we got from SMU, who will try to connect with the WR from Stanford. And, we will hope for good years from recognizable returning Cats, and then wish them well after the season as they portal off to Baylor, Oregon, ND, etc.
I bet you have a strong golf game too.

New NIL commission coming?

I feel of a lot of you would be much happier if you found something else to do than follow college sports.

I have no doubt many here would agree because it is no longer really "college" sports to them. But, we can look forward to the center from Missouri snapping to the QB we got from SMU, who will try to connect with the WR from Stanford. And, we will hope for good years from recognizable returning Cats, and then wish them well after the season as they portal off to Baylor, Oregon, ND, etc.

Are things about to get interesting with BB?

On a related note to figuring out the current NCAA eligibility rules, do the amateurism rules not exist anymore? How is it allowable that these European pros are coming to play in college? If those guys can play, can guys in the G League (or even fringe NBA guys) who still have eligibility come back to college and make way more than they make in the G League? If not, what’s the difference?
After Illinois got a commitment from its second professional player - I texted Illini son that NU was pursing LeBron and Giannis who both have four years of eligibility. But honestly what is to stop a guy who goes straight to the g league from high school from deciding at 22 when it’s clear he’s not going to the NBA from going to school and getting paid and getting a degree?

Here is the best take I’ve seen on this:

Login to view embedded media

Giving Credit Where Credit is Due

Do you think there were 3 better players than Martinelli on last years team?

If this changed your opinion on Audige how’d he score on your adjusted +\- that season and what’s that say about that metric?

Audige was 2nd best imo. Boo Buie was 1st team All big ten by the media and considered by almost everyone as the best player on that team. I would still take hobbled Barnhizer over a lot of players. He was still stuffing the stat sheet and being a lockdown defender.
Barnhizer's defense has improved by leaps and bounds since he arrived at Northwestern and couldn't guard his shadow. He's a capable and willing defender now, and I never thought he'd even get there. But "lockdown"...don't think so.

New NIL commission coming?

And what has the 18-year-old actually done to deserve such a reward?

The answer is nothing. Absolutely nothing except demonstrate that he is very good at throwing a football.

I don't blame the kid for taking the money. He would be foolish not to.

I blame the hyper-sports, hyper-TV, hyper-money rich donors for the problem. And don't leave out the money-making video action game business that I think also has had a big role in this problem.
Are you against an 18 year old making the same money from being a concert pianist or a painter?
Are you against, say a 25 year old, making the same money from being very good at throwing a football?

New NIL commission coming?

... What the 18 year old is getting is the same as a stock with a high PE ratio...
And what has the 18-year-old actually done to deserve such a reward?

The answer is nothing. Absolutely nothing except demonstrate that he is very good at throwing a football.

I don't blame the kid for taking the money. He would be foolish not to.

I blame the hyper-sports, hyper-TV, hyper-money rich donors for the problem. And don't leave out the money-making video action game business that I think also has had a big role in this problem.
  • Like
Reactions: No Chores

New NIL commission coming?

No one needs a remedial education in basic economics to understand that paying an eighteen-year-old millions of dollars simply because he is very good at throwing a football is fundamentally wrong. This is not an economics issue. It is a moral one that is significantly corrupting the values in our society.
It is economics. I agree with you viscerally, but I don’t economically. What the 18 year old is getting is the same as a stock with a high PE ratio. The NIL payer is investiing in future value. It may or may not be realized. If it is, the school gets wins, visibility, TV, ticket sales and teh NIL payer, like any donor, gets the satisfaction of having made it happen. But in the economic end, it’s an inveestment in a hoped for future, no different than a PE of 30 or 40.

Entertainment has moral value. From JS Mill to Singer ethicists have argued that a person should spend their resources to help a disadvantaged person until that spending materially reduces their own well-being. That’s probably the most moral use of one’s money but few of use will quite go there and we probably do overpay for our entertainment in terms of its marginal utility to us. But, that’s life.

2026 CB Joshua Sims flips commitment from Northwestern to Tulane

It's not back to how it used to be, it's a mildly more ordered version of now with a higher baseline. Everybody will have their baseline direct revenue sharing and then programs can build on top of that however much they want with external NIL dollars, which I believe I recall reading need to be reported. It's not a cap, it's a floor.
The big difference is NIL has to go through a clearing house to confirm its actual market value for each deal instead of enticement. So a kid can get an endorsement deal from a company or a booster business, but the deal has to be worth what it “should” be worth.

Most schools with big boosters are already planning to going back to paying under the table. As you said, revenue sharing is a floor. Teams are prepared to go well over that in the sports they care most about.
ADVERTISEMENT

Filter

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT