I appreciate your insight Mr Jango. I have been to a couple of NU practices and I definitely can feel the family atmosphere. I'm sure all football programs have that to a certain degree, I think NU remains more committed to this concept more than most. With many big time football programs, it seems like they are run more like an NFL franchise rather than a school trying to produce the best student-athletes. It seems almost unheard of these days to have long tenured assistant coaches but NU has a slew of them. It seems if you can't produce or get injured, they try to cut you any way they can.
I would love to beat Michigan and Ohio State as much as you do but that is quite a challenge. Those programs are stocked with NFL talent at almost every position. It's not impossible but incredibly challenging. Since Northwestern refuses to compromise academics for their athletes, NU probably can only recruit 20-25% of the football talent pool each year. This alone gives other programs a big advantage. While other observers seem to be enthralled by stars, I think they forget that out of the 250 or so 4 star or better players out there, NU can only offer around 40-50 of them each year. And that is nationwide. Then you throw in the fact that those big programs have the resources, crowds, and exposure equivalent of an NFL franchise.
NU does have one advantage though. It can offer a very rigorous academic environment as well as big time D1 football, a claim that only a few other schools can make. I think there will always be a few kids each year who will choose to take on that challenge instead of going to the football factories. I walked around NU's campus last year with one of my med school friends who attended Florida State. She said the atmosphere between the 2 schools are completely different. She said FSU was a big party school, with nonstop celebration occurring. She could tell that the students at NU take their academics very seriously. I love it when I see an NU recruit with Ivy league offers because I absolutely know that those schools would NOT offer an academically questionable athlete. NUs football graduation rate is crazy high at close to 100%, higher than the national average of all students. Nowadays, a D1 football athlete has about a 60% chance of graduating from college which I find sad. NU will never have a recruiting class that is completely full of blue chippers but I don't think you need that in order to have a successful program. You said as much when you pointed to Michigan State. I would much rather have the 2 and 3 star Vitales and Lowrys of the world that continue to improve and get better each year and then leave school with a degree. NU has done a strong job of identifying talent early in upstanding young men. So let the OSUs and Michigans of the world have their blue chippers. They will be part of the "family" until they fail to develop, suffer injury, break the law or flunk out of school.