ADVERTISEMENT

What if Collins ...

I think if and when the ACC fully dies, Duke is going to be staring that choice in the face TBH. Maintaining a legitimate football program outside a power conference while also having the right basketball opponents will be an issue. I GUESS they could try to go Gonzaga and rule the A10 or something, but... it's hard.

They could always hope UNC drags them with somewhere, it's plausible, they're a legitimate basketball brand that might make them one of the few truly profitable non-football revenue generators. Maybe at a partial share, kind of thing. I could see them landing a spot in the Big 12 or Big Ten that way.
I think if UNC could bring someone with them it would be NC st. At this point, I don’t think package deals are an option. We saw Oregon and Oregon st split, Washington and wash st split. Duke hoops might be a big enough brand that the BIG or SEC will take them. The future is definitely murky if you are a Duke fan

What if Collins ...

When K retired, it came down to Scheyer and Tommy Amaker, but Amaker didn’t want to leave Harvard to be K’s lead assistant for the final year and K would have had to push an assistant out to make that happen. (Why the heir apparent had to serve a year with K, I’m not sure, but that’s what Ian O’Connor’s book said.) There were too many potential successors at every point in the last two decades for Collins turn down a major-conference job and hope to wait it out.

As a Collins fan still apologetic about wanting him fired a few years ago, I’d love to see him get a shot at a top-10 or top-20 program just to see if he can win a natty. But that is outweighed by having him here.
I always thought that Collins helped get Scheyer the job. Collins tried to hire him to be his top assistant and I thought he said yes but then quietly returned to the bench at Duke. I just figured that they gave Scheyer a super quiet coach in waiting tag after that.

What if Collins ...

Big East is bball only. I don’t think Duke would leave the football program in the wilderness (see UCONN).
I think if and when the ACC fully dies, Duke is going to be staring that choice in the face TBH. Maintaining a legitimate football program outside a power conference while also having the right basketball opponents will be an issue. I GUESS they could try to go Gonzaga and rule the A10 or something, but... it's hard.

They could always hope UNC drags them with somewhere, it's plausible, they're a legitimate basketball brand that might make them one of the few truly profitable non-football revenue generators. Maybe at a partial share, kind of thing. I could see them landing a spot in the Big 12 or Big Ten that way.

A question of semantics….

No, but it's still a more reasonable way for any of us who are not involved to talk about it than to refer to it as independent payments unrelated to the school. You can be technically correct all day long without getting to the gist of what's going on.
I'm not here to be a pedant about colloquial conversations, but the question was asked why the word "payroll" didn't apply by somebody who seemed to be asking in good faith for better understanding of a topic we're all here to discuss, and so in the context of this conversation that is specifically about existing structures and the words to describe them, I felt an ACCURATE answer was important.

In literally like two months this distinction will be further blurred as there will be "internal NIL/revenue sharing" which will probably not legally be payroll right away but would be totally fair to describe as functioning exactly like a payroll (and maybe before long a court action will declare it to LITERALLY be payroll, I don't know, I'd bet on it it TBH), and external NIL (which in itself is already split into the sort of coach-influenced collective NIL, independent booster NIL, and actual endorsement NIL). So this existing distinction has a short expiration date on it.
  • Like
Reactions: PURPLECAT88
ADVERTISEMENT

Filter

ADVERTISEMENT